Job growth is slow. And in some quarters, they’re blaming (1) high taxes, (2) the deficit, or (3) a socialist conspiracy. But if you look at the numbers, it isn’t taxes or federal spending that’s keeping job growth low. Taxes are at their lowest since 1992 for the top bracket, and are pretty close to where they were in the Reagan years. But during the economic boom of the 199os, taxes were higher for the top bracket earners, and there was much higher overall employment.
The deficit certainly is an issue for long-term economic stability. And yes, US government borrowing does soak up capital. But the bond rates that the US pays on debt are minuscule, and, in a perfect neoliberal capitalist world, investors would make capital available for businesses looking to grow from a position of strength because of the potential return on investment. Right?
Yeah, I know. Theory is boring, facts are boring. And we still have 9% unemployment. Why is that, if it isn’t because the government is weighing down business with taxes and its bloated debt?
Here’s why:
1) Higher labor productivity means that companies can make big profits off of smaller revenues, so there’s not as much incentive to grow them. Take a look at the Bureau of Labor and Statistics‘ numbers on productivity, and you’ll see that productivity has grown in some sectors by more than 100% over the last 5 years (and is starting to reach a plateau). The cost of labor has trailed productivity during that time, and real wages have dropped on average — because of the larger pool of unemployed, salary cuts and other factors. So, companies can make more with fewer workers. That would theoretically lead to profits that fuel big growth, but…
2) Energy costs are high because of speculation and huge demand from China and India, who have economies that are rapidly growing. So the non-labor costs of production, which are largely based on energy and other commodity costs, have gone up. So instead of ramping up production, companies have found that they can produce the same or less, with fewer employees, and rake in profits while holding production costs down. And if they do ramp up their production…
3) Manufacturing has been shifted overseas, so the increased production has a lesser impact on US hiring. So job growth remains low. Job growth could take off if companies in emerging areas were hiring here, but…
4) Congress cut funding of green tech. And there could be big gains in efficiency in healthcare and a significant reduction in the financial burden on companies from health insurance premiums, but…
5) The Republicans want to rescind the Affordable Healthcare Act and kill Medicare just as they’re starting to pressure a change in the business model of healthcare that will shift to value versus volume. And of course, we bailed out the banks, but…
6) The glut of foreclosed housing from the mortgage disaster and other factors have depressed housing prices, and the construction industry, which was a major employer of semi-skilled labor, is still recovering. And it’s been living on corporate welfare life support for the last decade, at least.
